Are you an “Echoist”? What it is and how to overcome it.

Quote by Dr. Wayne Dyer; Meme from Facebook

Narcissism is the topic du jour. We’re programmed to beware of gaslighting and avoid the red flags of extreme selfishness and a craving for attention. But the reverse – having no narcissism – isn’t any healthier, experts warn. In fact, it can be be equally as damaging.

This trauma response is called echoism, a term popularized by psychologist Craig Malkin, to describe many victims of narcissistic abuse who fear being the center of attention. Those familiar with Greek mythology may recognize the name from the story of Narcissus, a hunter in love with his own reflection, and his romantic admirer Echo, a nymph cursed to repeat back the last few words she hears.

Like their namesake, echoists “struggle to have a voice of their own,” says Malkin, a lecturer at Harvard Medical School who wrote “Rethinking Narcissism: The Secret to Recognizing and Coping with Narcissists.” “They often echo the needs and feelings of others,” and the result is a unique vulnerability to toxic relationships that perpetuate a cycle of abuse and silence.

‘Echoists’ are prone to narcissistic, emotionally abusive relationships. Is this you? Jenna Ryu, USA TODAY,
Tue, August 23, 2022 at 9:03 PM
Quote by Nedra Tawwab; meme from tinybuddha.com

Trauma responses are very real and they subtly alter our behaviors and patterns of thinking, shifting us more and more away from a healthy, balanced point towards adaptive behaviors which severely alter our sense of self. The changes can happen so gradually that our sense of what is normal devolves into our “new normal”.

We usually don’t realize how crazy and messed up life has become until we pull away from it and are able to look at it from the outside.

While we’re in it our survival skills are in full gear, so our brains try to create some kind of sense of normalcy, which blinds us to how bad things actually are.

Survivalism is very necessary for many situations where there is physical threat and danger, and where there is emotionally crippling and wounding occurring. The key thing to do in those circumstances is to survive.

Survivalism calls for adaptive behaviors we wouldn’t otherwise engage in, and if continued over the long-term, can lead us and our families into thinking this really IS normal, yet it isn’t.

People who live through these experiences tend to struggle with mental health issues, depression, and anxiety coming to the top of the list, along with a host of other issues.

When we’ve come to believe that what we’ve come out of or are currently living with is normal, and everyone else in the family believes it too, the person who struggles with mental health issues brought on by these situations is made to feel as though there is something wrong with THEM.

“They lose their own ability to know their mind, to speak their own mind and to have their own feelings. They just exist to put someone else at the forefront and thereafter, they’re fearful of taking the limelight,” Harpur explains. Other common indicators include repeated romantic or platonic relationships with narcissists, low self-esteem, an inability to set boundaries and a fear of upsetting others.

‘Echoists’ are prone to narcissistic, emotionally abusive relationships. Is this you? Jenna Ryu, USA TODAY,
Tue, August 23, 2022 at 9:03 PM

It’s difficult for many families to admit that the abusive narcissist who leads or rules the household has been able to alter everyone’s perception of reality in such deep ways, that their “happy” (on the outside at least) family is just a facade, and that no one is really happy.

Justifications become the norm to excuse the abusive narcissist. “He’s a good provider”, “He’s a pillar in the community”, and “He’s a good guy under all the toughness” are some of the justifications which get thrown around.

“It’s not really all that bad” is a lie that is often told to ourselves and to one another, because the thought of “breaking up a family” is one of the most difficult decisions we can ever make.

People who come from highly “traditional” or religious families usually end up trying to brush a lot under the rug, to force themselves to maintain the facade of successfully living with the abuser, because for years they’ve heard how “non-churchgoers” or “non-traditional people” simply don’t hold to the same values, and that the future of the wellbeing of the entire community depends upon them not leaving.

Wow. That’s a lot of pressure to put on people.

What incredible pressure to conform to any abuses in the name of holding their community together.

So people tend to suffer in silence. They don’t want to rock the boat or appear to be out of step with those around them, because THE COMMUNITY IS DEPENDING ON THEM.

Bollocks! It’s completely unhealthy to pretend that abusive situations are healthy or normal.

Sadly, the only ones who are fooled by these ways of thinking are those living it and doing their best to pretend all is good. People on the outside of the community or family often see the truth, but won’t say anything.

Two extreme ends lie on the spectrum of narcissismOne is the narcissism we know and hate: the entitlement, lack of empathy and abusive behavior wreaking havoc on a victim’s life. On the other end is echoism, a more silent condition just as concerning.

Both Malkin and Harpur agree that a hint of narcissism can be healthy. While a pathological narcissist is “blind” to the consequences of their behaviors, a healthy narcissist – albeit with some arrogance – will ultimately be “responsive to feedback and if they make mistakes, it’s not crushing to them. It just becomes something they have to navigate and accept,” Harpur says.

In fact, an innate desire to feel recognized for your accomplishments drives people to try new things, expand their interests and grow. But an echoist who fears seeming narcissistic may repress their true personality and fail to self-enhance or make meaningful connections – a phenomenon scientifically related to anxiety and depression.

“We need to feel a little special in order to be happy and healthy and to thrive,” Malkin says. “If you are so intensely fearful of taking up any attention or of expressing your needs in a relationship, other people miss out on connecting with you … and if the person is so uncomfortable with having focus on them, they’re going to prefer to be with somebody who takes up all the room” – resulting in a special attachment to narcissists.

‘Echoists’ are prone to narcissistic, emotionally abusive relationships. Is this you? Jenna Ryu, USA TODAY,
Tue, August 23, 2022 at 9:03 PM

Overcoming being an Echoist

Overcoming being an Echoist is going to be a multi-step process, for there’s going to be a lot of unlearning which needs to be done, but it is best accomplished by learning new positive behaviors and slowly implementing them.

The more we try to force ourselves NOT to do something, the more difficult life gets. Instead, we really need to focus on slowly incorporating new behaviors and thoughts into our lives.

I heard a beautiful analogy years ago which illustrates this process.

Imagine a glass of dirty water. We want to be able to drink clean water from the glass, but we can’t tip out the dirty water. How can we accomplish this?

When we place the glass of dirty water under the faucet and allow clean water to pour in, eventually enough clean water displaces the dirty water.

This perfectly illustrates how our emotions work.

We can’t empty ourselves of our emotions, but we can learn new thought processes and behaviors to gradually displace the old unhealthy ones.

Reclaiming our God-given rights to think for ourselves, to be our own person, and to be able to spend life living and not simply surviving is vitally important to our mental health and to developing happiness and peace within ourselves.

@jenpeters soulguide healer
click to go to the article

If anything in this post has spoken to you and you wish to learn more, I hope you’ll poke around my Archived Posts to find a wonderful trove of supportive and encouraging posts!

I’m sharing more posts that may be helpful for you:

More good stuff:

Blessings!
Thank you for sharing this post and for following me!
Tamara
https://tamarakulish.com/ Archived Posts: https://tamarakulish.com/archived-posts/

My books: Now available through Walmart.com!

Developing Happiness When You Can’t Find It and How to Heal Your Life on a Deep Heart Level are available in paperback and Kindle. Audio book available!

Guided Journals help you work on a particular issue by answering questions to help see patterns and to find solutions:

Removing Inner Blocks,    Anger Journal,    Guided Anxiety Journal    Joy & Mindfulness Journal     My Boundaries Journal   My Inner Thoughts Journal   

Thanks for buying my books on Amazon!

#writing #InspirationalWriting #journalwriting #art #creativity #strength #guru #mentor #teacher #HappinessGuru #TamaraHappinessGuru #TamaraKulish #Tamara #HappinessMentor, #love #growth #healing #life, #inspiration, #quotes #happiness #joy #PersonalGrowth #pain #depression #anxiety #SelfEsteem, #LifeSkills #empowerment #encouragement #support #intuition #journal #consciousness #mind #learn #God #universe #angels #spiritual #spirit #awareness #journaling #journal #boundaries #emotionalhealth #mentalhealth #emotions #control #Amazon #Kindle #Twitter #Goodreads #Facebook #blog #author #publishing #encouragement #angermanagement #artjournal #ColoringBooks

15 thoughts on “Are you an “Echoist”? What it is and how to overcome it.

    1. Right?! Looking back I see I was more of an echoist than I wanted to admit at the time, but honestly allows us to make truer assessments and move forward. I see in your writings that you are indeed working through those old beliefs. Kudos!

      Liked by 1 person

  1. We put a lot of coping strategies in place as children to try to understand this life and ‘fit in’. Not realizing just how damaging they are because of our immaturity, and can only learn from those that are passing on their fears anyway. Hard, oh very yes…but slowly teaching us to love ourselves as we get older, and sometimes not for many, many years. But, and thankfully, all of life leaves scars. Heartfelt ones, but these are the ones that teach us empathy and compassion, the greatest teachers of love. If you ask me to relate to someone who has had a blessed life, barely a blip on their radar, I will find someone who has no empathy or compassion because they have not gone through anything to build them. But give me someone who has been dragged by their hearts through so many puddles and I will feel the love this person has built. Yes, it is very hard indeed Tamara, and there are thankfully people like you to help those journeys so that it is more guided and understood. And I know the flower that will blossom because of it all. This world does indeed teach something very beautiful and profound but occasionally we have to trip and stumble to show its light among it. Great post dear lady, may it help the many on this journey 😀❤️🙏🏽

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks so much, Mark! As always, I deeply appreciate your heartfelt and wise observances of life and people! Indeed, the people who tend to love the deepest are those who have been deeply scarred. You are so right, coping mechanisms often get developed quite early in life and continue through much of our lives, unless we take the steps to make changes. Change is difficult, but staying wounded or struggling to cope hurts much more! Blessings, and thanks so much for paying a visit! You are always welcome!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’d never heard of echoists before but this makes so much sense. It’s been years so I had to deal with my narcissistic business partner but boy did this bring back memories. Thanks for the info and strategies!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. My pleasure! I hadn’t heard of this before either, so I was intrigued to learn more. Like you, when I read the linked article, My mind brought me back to those years. I don’t know if knowing there was an actual title to the behavior would have helped me, but looking back I can see how my behavior was affected. The more information we have, the better we can navigate through our issues!

      Like

        1. LOL! Thanks, Devang! One never knows for certain anything about another person, that’s why I said “may” since I have no idea! That would be your choice to share or not, as you wish! I’m always delighted to hear that my writing is helpful to others! I hope this info will be of benefit to you and to others in your circle!

          Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s